Have you seen the piece by Katrina Gulliver, on how she doesn't like students calling her by her first name? She's funny and self-deprecating, writing like she's internalized the critical voice that will indeed soon enough tell her to lighten up, already. Gulliver's take on the first name issue is about how she has to work hard to get respect in the classroom. Intriguingly, she calls out her white male colleagues for trying to be cool and wearing really casual clothing and inviting students to call them by their first names. She says these guys might be deflating a tiny bit of their own authority, but demolish hers.
Will Miller wrote an incredibly smug response, that mocks Gulliver in taking the very structure of her opening to turn it back on her, disavowing her claims: "If what students call me determines whether I am respected or not, I’m not deserving to be in a classroom." Miller, unsurprisingly, seems completely at ease in his own prose, without the faintest whiff of self-reflexivity jarring his lightly sarcastic and righteous tone.
Ugh. This is making me tired. This is a feminist blog and you know our politics so I'll just lay it out: this is the epitome of clueless (in this case white, male) privilege. It's snotty, and silencing, and smug, and denies Gulliver's experience. Will Miller: stahhhhhhp.
I don't want to argue this. I want to start a grounded conversation about the how's and why's of managing one's authority in teaching. Erin wrote about the first name issue. I did, too, in a post about email. And we've had a post about the politics of eyewear. And one on how people treat me nicer when I look pretty than when I don't. Melissa has written about haircuts and so have I. And boots! All of these produced great, useful discussions: what's great is hearing about other people's experiences and strategies even if and especially when they differ from my own. Read the comments: they're thoughtful and engaging and awesome!
I want to talk about my clothing choices and ask you to share yours, if you'd like.
My current positionality is this: mid-career tenured academic, coming
into an administrative post in July, 41 and mostly look it, white, cis-gendered, not visibly
disabled, normative height / weight range, conventionally pretty.
Privileged also in the sense that I'm pretty fluent in the rhetoric of
clothing, and adept at constructing (and having access to the tools to
construct) grammatically correct utterances in this language.
Me, I'm all about blazers lately. Nothing connotes immediate authority like a blazer. Mine all feature rolled up sleeves, so it's more fashion-forward than banker-bland, but there's something very comforting to me about the work jacket. I'll wear it over a dress, or with a skirt, or dress pants. I can even wear my beloved black yoga jeans and the jacket makes it work appropriate. I have blazers (with suits and not) in: rust/black herringbone wool, grey wool, grey cotton, black wool, navy wool, chartreuse cotton, blue suede (yes!). Most were on sale, some were full price, two were from consignment shops, but they read "expensive" and "tasteful." I often take it off to teach, but put it back on for meetings of all sorts. I keep one in my office, in case I happen to be without, and I need one.
Sometimes I'm in situations where I'm the only person under 45, and the
only woman who's not an adminstrative assistant to some older man.
Sometimes I'm teaching 17 year old. Sometimes I'm on TV. Blazer on / blazer off, like glasses / contacts are choices I can make fairly easily that allow me to manipulate others' perceptions of me, and thus, manage my interaction with them, in some small way. Bear in mind that I have dramatically two-toned hair, and that I wear fashion-forward nailpolish (today nine fingers are mint green and one is sunshine yellow). The blazer is part of the whole package.
How about you? Maybe you are like Steve Jobs and hate to think about clothes and have a functional uniform. Maybe you are junior and trying to stay fashionable and a very limited budget. Maybe you are a little older and thinking about appropriateness. Or something else. Please share!