The answer, I suggest, is largely structural rather than individual. I have ideas, ideas that have to do with structure and accountability, just like all my other ideas.
Let me present you with Morrison's Law of Academic Writing, as a chart. I drew it on a piece of paper:
|Morrison's Law of Academic Writing|
Writing happens where Baseline Fear and Deadline Fear intersect: this is the point for many writers where the fear of consequence for not writing exceed the fear or writing.
This is not ideal. If you want to get the writing started sooner, one of two things has to happen: either you reduce the base line of writing fear (which we've discussed, mostly by lowering your standards and cultivating a daily writing habit), or by dramatically accelerating the crisis points in the Terror Curve.
Consider coursework. Each seminar lasts a mere 12 weeks. Every single week, students have to show up in class, and demonstrate that they're read the material. Often, mid-semester, students have to produce a formal proposal for their final paper, and hand it in for grades. They might have to do an annotated bibliography a few weeks later, and then there is a hard deadline for the paper shortly after the semester ends. Courses usually culminate with a research paper, but the weekly reading deadlines, and scaffolded writing assignments mean there are lots of shorter and less dramatic Terror Curves, with lower stakes, that may in turn reduce the Baseline Writing Fear.
In chart form: Note how manageable this looks. Note that the Baseline Writing Fear is lower because the stakes are lower. Note that writing happens at many points in the semester. Note that the Terror Peaks are not at very high fear threshold points.
|The Terror Curve in coursework|
But how do we organize dissertation writing? Proposal complete, students are set entirely loose, with an injunction to "write something" and then, when they deem that something is somehow ready in some way for some kind of feedback, to turn it in. The only real deadline is Dissertation Defense, which isn't a date until the thing is actually done, but there are other deadlines that are squishier or aspirational like "finish within four years."
Here is the dissertation in chart form. Note that the Baseline Writing Fear is high to start, because no one has written a dissertation before and doesn't know how, and also this is the Main Goal of the PhD. Note that the Terror Curve is dramatically bent -- the timeline, usually about two years, is very long, allowing for major non-writing to happen, with dramatic shooting up of terror level right at the end. The Baseline Writing Fear is usually much higher for the dissertation project than for any other writing the student has ever done, because it's not only a huge piece of writing, but in a genre the student has never written in before, with the added bonus of being incredibly high stakes.
|The Terrifying Dissertation Curve|
What I often see but wish I didn't is students writing the entire dissertation in the red zone of the terror curve: trying to do a whole dissertation in 6 months, rushing it, miserable, producing poor work. What I want to see is steadier writing, more enjoyably, with real time for revision and rethinking and savoring the process (really.)
So here is Morrison's Theory of Supervisory Terror. I am the terror curve for my students. Don't get me wrong! I'm not scary and I'm not mean. But I *am* the deadline that their work otherwise lacks. I push the moment of reckoning dramatically forward, and lower the stakes, so that the writing gets done sooner and better and more easily.
Map it like this:
|Morrison's Theory of Supervisory Terror|
The details are unique to each student, and negotiated. Some students book regular office visits with me. Some send me writing every week that I don't read. Some produce detailed timelines of chapter deadlines and revision schedules. The key thing is, we determine what kind of push or prompt they need from me to ensure that they will stay accountable to their own projects.
It works at the program level too. Annual progress reports where students really account for their year of writing, and a meeting to make plans, that can work. Once-per-semester meetings with students beyond program limits, to discuss progress and celebrate it and plan it. Anything that lets students know that we expect them to get some writing done, and we will be discussing it sometime in the next couple of months makes it more likely that it becomes scarier NOT to write than it would be TO write.
Can I tell you? I failed more than one class in my undergrad because I just didn't write the essays. I didn't write them because I'm an anxious perfectionist with time management problems. This is why, incidentally, I like sit-down exams and in-class essays so much. Anyhow, these classes I failed usually had a mid-term essay, that I didn't hand in and was told to just hand it in whenever, and a final essay, that I also didn't hand in, because I still had to write the mid-term essay and I was full of shame and loathing. If the class also had a final exam, I would ace it, and then the prof would call me and wonder why why why I just didn't get the writing done, because I was obviously so damn smart and had clearly read and understood everything. When you fall so far behind, and no one is really holding you to it, it's easy to get rid of all the shame and fear by just not doing anything at all. I don't want my students to suffer like this. This is not an uncommon problem among academics.
Ultimately, it would be better if we wrote without fear. That comes, eventually, from making writing a habit, being steady, and seeing the results. Most of us don't get there without some training, and some practice, and that comes from accountability. We need more training and mentoring too, obviously, but a really easy piece is the accountability.
Oh -- about the charts? I was going to do them all fancy on the computer, but I didn't have time, because I need to finish this blog post and do some writing on my book chapter. My writing coach and I set a deadline, and it's only three weeks away ...